Industrialization and the Rise of a Regulated Economy

Industrialization and the Rise of a Regulated Economy

Industrialization and the Rise of a Regulated Economy

The United States went through dramatic economic change during and after the Civil War, as industrialization spread rapidly and changed society. This transformation and some of the apparent abuses that developed (monopolistic practices, work conditions, low wages, arbitrary and oppressive expectations) led to an increased role of the government in regulating businesses and society. Government might intervene on the side of business owners for a variety of reasons. Or it might intervene on the side of workers. Or it might intervene for more general reasons. This role was heightened as government was viewed as the arbiter between business and organized labor. One can explore these developments from 1865 on through to the end of the 1930s. Examine the statements below and drawing from provided sources, present a paper with specific examples and arguments to demonstrate the validity of your position.

Topic and Thesis Statement—choose one of the following as your Thesis Statement:

THESIS STATEMENT 1: From the late 1800s to the end of the 1930s, increasing government interventions and regulations of business tended to help the overall economy and the common workers.

THESIS STATEMENT 2: From the late 1800s to the end of the 1930s, increasing government interventions and regulations of business tended to hurt the overall economy and the common workers.

Plan to make that thesis statement the last sentence in your introductory paragraph. The general subject is government economic interventions and regulations in that period of history. You may moderate the wording slightly to fit more precisely the position you wish to take. This is NOT a simple statement of a topic; it is a statement of a position you are taking about that topic. p.s.—Valid arguments and “A” papers can be made with either thesis. So, you choose the one you think is the stronger position.

After giving general consideration to your readings so far and any general research, select one of the positions above as your position—your thesis. (Sometimes after doing more thorough research, you might choose the reverse position. This happens with critical thinking and inquiry. Your final paper might end up taking a different position than you originally envisioned.) Organize your paper as follows, handling these issues:

Part 1: Introductory paragraph with thesis statement. The thesis statement should be the last sentence in your opening paragraph.
Part 2: FOUR EXAMPLES–To support your position, use four specific examples from different decades between 1865 and 1940. However, one of your four examples must be from the 1930s.
Part 3: Explain why the opposing view is weak in comparison to yours. The opposing view is the thesis statement you did not choose.
Part 4: Legacy today and conclusion. Consider your life today: In what way does the history you have shown shape or impact issues in your workplace or desired profession?

Length: The paper should be 500-to-750 words in length.

Research and References: You must use a MINIMUM of three sources; the Schultz textbook must be one of them. Your other two sources should be drawn from the list provided on the instruction sheet. This is guided research, not Googling.

 [THIS IS A FORMAT SAMPLE for doing Assignment 2 using our ecree platform. This sample illustrates the FOUR-PART organization that the instruction sheet asks for. And it illustrates in-text citations in the body of the paper and it illustrates the Sources list at the end. The usual SWS form calls for double spacing and a title page (so did APA)—but when we use ecree (as in this HIS105 class), we won’t use double-spacing or a title page. However, it will be important to write good quality, distinct paragraphs and to organize the paper in the four-part structure called for by the instructions. So, this “format sample” of Assignment 2 has no title page and is single-spaced—except between paragraphs and between source entries at the end. It still has in-text citations (see samples in the second paragraph below) and it still has the sources list at the end—you do need those. As required by the instructions, the sources used in this sample are from the REQUIRED list on the instructions sheet. This sample does not really help you on content, but this gives you guidance on each part of the paper—and illustrates the four-part set-up of the paper and the sourcing. You have the choice of typing a paper set-up like this sample on a MS-Word file (see the TEMPLATE) and then copy/pasting it to ecree one paragraph at a time, or you can type your paper directly into ecree—using this same sort of set-up. Regulations Helping our Economy is the sample title here—and I put it with the first paragraph. (with another thesis, you might choose Regulations Hurting our Economy). Feel free to word your title to fit your thesis. ]

Regulations Helping our Economy– PART ONE: INTRODUCTION WITH THESIS Notice how this first line of the paragraph and the heading can go together in this ecree approach to the paper. The PART ONE heading is optional, but probably useful for your own clarity while writing and my clarity when I grade it. You have no worry here about indenting or double-spacing; not needed or wanted for ecree. In terms of content, a format sample like this does not provide that—this sheet just shows the form and organization—and samples of citing. And I provide a few tips here. Keep in mind the paper mostly focuses on a long period—from 1865 to the 1930s; and you will eventually need specific examples from four different decades in that period (and one example MUST be from the 1930s). But, in this first paragraph, you will have an introduction to your paper and you will also include your thesis statement as the last sentence of the paragraph. Perhaps you feel that overall the government interventions and regulations of the era did prove beneficial to the overall economy and to common workers. Or, perhaps you feel the government interventions of the era, whatever their intent, usually hurt the overall economy and the common workers. In the late 1800s and early 1900s, most government economic regulations were supported by the “Progressive” reform movements of the day—a term you see much in chapter 19. But, by the 1930s (chapter 22), government economic interventions are associated with a new label—Roosevelt’s New Deal, a wide-ranging program attempting to address the problems of the Great Depression. As you explore the class text for examples, chapters 16 through 22 may be reviewed. Keep in mind, you want FOUR EXAMPLES from different decades—and one of them from the 1930s. How do you view these things? Will your thesis statement be something like this?: From the late 1800s to the end of the 1930s, increasing government interventions and regulations of business tended to help the overall economy and the common workers. Or, perhaps you will you take this position: From the late 1800s to the end of the 1930s, increasing government interventions and regulations of business tended to hurt the overall economy and the common workers.

PART TWO—FOUR EXAMPLES: The second and third paragraphs will cover your four SPECIFIC examples supporting your thesis. Caution—don’t get bogged down in describing long trends here, or events that don’t support your thesis. At times the government got involved in stopping labor strikes (Schultz, 1, p. 324). At other times it guaranteed the right to form labor unions (Schultz, 1, p. 425). Leonard (2) describes a progressive commission’s work in 1913-1916 that led many states to adopt legislation on “minimum-wage, maximum-hour, and working conditions” (p. 128), and many debate the benefits of such mandates. Even as early as 1871, a report like that by Whitaker (3) on unhealthy factory conditions might be used as a reason for regulating the workplace. But don’t forget: Some sources are good for illustrating the need for government intervention or even show support for government intervention. You still need examples of actual government intervention or regulation. Government intervention with the 18thAmendment made illegal the “manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors” (Schultz, 1, p. 402); we know this by the term “Prohibition”. Besides choosing an example, you also must determine whether or not you feel such regulation was beneficial. Notice that in the lines above you have illustrations of what SWS style in-text citations look like. In each case, you see the number matches the number on the list at the end. For a book like Schultz, you should always include a page number as well.

EXAMPLES CONTINUED–In this part of the paper you really start developing the topic and your position and evidence. One can also think of the Sherman Antitrust Act, the Pure Food and Drug Act, and the formation of the Federal Trade Commission. It normally takes two paragraphs to cover your four examples, but stay focused on the examples and don’t get sidetracked from supporting your thesis. Be concise. By the way, you can make valid arguments for either thesis, and present an “A” paper in doing so. The assignment requires you to use the Schultz textbook and at least two other sources from the list on the instruction sheet (don’t use other sources not listed). Since those sources are listed in SWS form and also have a convenient link with them, one can easily copy/paste the ones you use for your sources list at the end. And, with the link, each source is very easy to access.

PART THREE: DEALING WITH AN OPPOSING VIEW This third section of the paper involves some critical thinking on your part. How might a reasonable person disagree with you and give a different position or counter-argument? Keep this in mind—they are opposing the THESIS you chose to argue for in your paper. So, in effect, think of them as adopting the other thesis—the one you did not choose. For example, perhaps you argued that government interventions and regulations of business tended to be beneficial in this period. The opposing view would be that that government interventions of that period tended to have negative effects.

In that sort of situation, then start this paragraph by saying something like this: “Someone may disagree with my view and argue that government interventions of that period (1865 to the 1930s) tended to hurt the economy by bringing added costs and burdens to businesses.” After identifying that opposing thesis, then spend 3-to-5 sentences giving a reasoned argument why your thesis is stronger. (Caution—don’t be dismissive of those who disagree with you.) Now—having considered this illustration, you can also reverse the roles depending on what thesis you selected. Normally, this part is not so much doing more research or providing more examples. Instead it is about suggesting what that different position might be, and then your own logical rationale for favoring your own position instead. It is just critical thinking on your part.


This fourth and concluding paragraph of the paper does not normally involve researching information. It does involve some reflection about the issues covered in your paper and ways those issues perhaps are still around (maybe in a different form). In any profession that you are currently in or to which you aspire, there are numerous government regulations. Are they good? Are they burdensome paperwork for new businesses? Safety rules, tax and pay records, hiring regulations and records, standards on hours and wages, etc. Social security withholding. As the seeds of such things were born in the era studied in this paper, you should think of ways to connect the modern situation to the history you have written about. Again, this fourth part is normally a paragraph or so—lengthy treatment not needed here. This fourth part should normally serve as the conclusion of the paper. Be sure your paper ends in some way that wraps up succinctly. FOR SOURCES–Then, in ecree, click on the word “Conclusion” to add new paragraph boxes below it that you can use for source entries—it works best if you can get each source into its own paragraph box. As below, each source must be numbered and should be in SWS style (as can be copied from the instruction sheet). Just do your best with ecree.


Kevin M. Schultz. 2018. HIST: Volume 2: U.S. History since 1865. 5th ed.

T. C. Leonard. Spring, 2009. American Economic Reform in the Progressive Era: Its Foundational Beliefs and their Relation to Eugenics.

J. Whitaker. 1871. The Impact of the Factory on Worker Health. Retrieved from…

[Tips—number the sources list. For each entry, simply copy the form of that source as listed on the INSTRUCTIONS sheet. Be sure to use ONLY the Schultz textbook and two or more other sources on that list…no googling elsewhere. Keep it simple—the sources are provided for you. Each source listed must ALSO be cited with a short in-text citation in the body of your paper. The second paragraph in this sample illustrates what those in-text citations might look like. ]

[LAYOUT in ECREE of your sources list: This sometimes poses a problem, as the ecree tool is being worked on for improvement in this respect. Once you finish that last paragraph in ecree, click on the word “Conclusion” to add new paragraph boxes—it works best if you can get each source into its own paragraph box. In general, I suggest getting your paragraphs and content into ecree first, then worrying about the paragraph labels on the left of the screen after that. As on the sample sources list above, each source must be numbered and should be in SWS style (as can be copied from the instruction sheet). Do your best on this last part, but don’t worry if you can’t get the layout just right in ecree. Your final essay paragraph will ideally be in the box “Conclusion”. Once typed, then click on that word “Conclusion and it will create a new box below with three dots. Keep clicking “Conclusion” until you have 4 or more “three-dot” boxes—one for the heading Sources and one for each source entry on your list of sources. If you cannot quite get this to work, don’t worry about it—just be sure you have a final

Solution preview for the order on industrialization and the Rise of a Regulated Economy

Industrialization and the Rise of a Regulated Economy


721 words